North Carolina
Through Executive Orders, North Carolina provides limited shield law protections (PDF, opens in a new tab) against state agency assistance, arrests, and extradition related to investigations and prosecutions of reproductive health care. North Carolina’s Executive Order does not offer similar protections for gender-affirming care.
Although North Carolina would benefit from many of the protections common among shield states, North Carolina should first strengthen its protections for providers, helpers, and patients by focusing on these policy priorities:
Repeal Telehealth Abortion Restrictions and Explicitly Protect Telehealth Care Regardless of Patient Location
Codify Shield Protections in Statute
Executive Orders can be rescinded by the Governor without reason or notice, subjecting people providing, accessing, or assisting in abortion and gender-affirming care in North Carolina to the uncertainty and legal vulnerability of shifting political winds. Codifying shield protections in statute would more securely guard North Carolina providers, patients, and helpers, making the state a more supportive location in which to provide and receive care. When the opportunity arises, North Carolina should prioritize comprehensive shield law legislation.
Explicitly Protect Gender-Affirming Care
Like reproductive health care, gender-affirming care has been increasingly politicized and access to care has been severely restricted in many states, especially for young people. Gender-affirming care providers, helpers, and patients continue to be targeted by hostile investigations and require robust legal protections similar to those needed to preserve abortion access. When the opportunity arises, North Carolina should prioritize extending legal protections to those providing, seeking, and helping with the provision of gender-affirming care.
Repeal Telehealth Abortion Restrictions and Explicitly Protect Telehealth Care Regardless of Patient Location
North Carolina law prohibits providers from using telehealth for abortion care. Telehealth provides a critical access point for people unable to travel to receive care or living in states with restrictions on abortion and gender-affirming care. Telehealth abortion care delivered by shield state providers accounts for close to 100% (opens in a new tab) of abortions accessed by people living in states where abortion is banned. A single telehealth provider can ensure access to time-sensitive health care for countless abortion and gender-affirming care patients each month. Currently, eight shield law states explicitly protect provision of care regardless of patient location, which includes telehealth care. By joining these eight states in enacting shield laws that explicitly apply regardless of patient location, North Carolina would offer its providers the strongest protections for offering care through telehealth, including to out-of-state patients. When the opportunity arises, North Carolina should prioritize repealing the existing ban and protecting telehealth abortion access regardless of patient location.
Protect Providers from Licensure Consequences
North Carolina providers who treat patients from states where abortion or gender-affirming care is restricted may face professional disciplinary actions that jeopardize their professional licensure and livelihood in North Carolina — even when providing care that is legal in North Carolina. Many shield providers are not comfortable treating patients from other states without licensure protections. North Carolina’s lack of licensure protections poses a barrier to provider participation and access to care. When the opportunity arises, North Carolina should prioritize licensure protections for shield providers. In the interim, Governor Stein should direct executive agencies through an executive order to work with professional boards to consider licensure protections for North Carolina providers.
Protect Against Another State’s Laws and Judgments Penalizing Health Care
Both states and private actors have used civil lawsuits (PDF, opens in a new tab) to attempt to penalize health care providers for offering reproductive and gender-affirming care. Some shield states have enacted laws preventing their courts from enforcing the laws or judgments of another state that penalize abortion and gender-affirming care. Others have enacted “clawback provisions” enabling those subjected to out-of-state lawsuits related to protected care to recover damages from hostile litigation. When the opportunity arises, North Carolina should prioritize policies protecting providers from the civil laws and judgments of states that ban and restrict health care.
Protect Against Hostile Search Warrants, Subpoenas, and Witness Summons
In their aggressive efforts to penalize reproductive and gender-affirming care, states and private actors have conducted sweeping searches and issued legal demands for medical and other personal information from hospitals, financial institutions, and technology companies. Many shield states have enacted laws that protect against the issuance of search warrants, subpoenas, and witness summons if sought in an investigation or action to penalize reproductive or gender-affirming health care. These shield laws are designed to protect provider and patient privacy and prevent hostile states and actors from gaining access to the information they need to build a legal action against someone for offering, receiving, or assisting in care. When the opportunity arises, North Carolina should prioritize policies that safeguard against hostile out-of-state search warrants, subpoenas, and witness summons targeting reproductive and gender-affirming care.