States and private actors are increasingly pursuing criminal and civil actions against health care providers for abortion and gender-affirming care. Shield laws designed to protect the provision of care, regardless of patient location, and to safeguard patient and provider privacy have become more important in light of these growing legal threats.

While there are many different types (opens in a new tab) of shield law protections, and each state’s (opens in a new tab) existing laws and unique circumstances may call for specific policy solutions, below, we identify the most urgent policy priorities all states should consider this year.

01

Explicitly Protect Telehealth Care Regardless of Patient Location

02

Protect Against Another State’s Laws and Judgments Penalizing Health Care

03

Protect Provider Privacy on Medication Labels

04

Prevent Disclosure of Patients’ Medical Information

01

Explicitly Protect Telehealth Care Regardless of Patient Location

Telehealth provides a critical access point for people unable to travel to receive care or living in states with restrictions on abortion and gender-affirming care. Telehealth abortion care delivered by shield state providers accounts for close to 100% (opens in a new tab) of abortions accessed by people living in states where abortion is banned. A single telehealth provider can ensure access to time-sensitive health care for countless abortion and gender-affirming care patients each month. Currently, eight shield law states explicitly protect provision of care regardless of patient location, which includes telehealth care. Every state that joins these eight states in enacting shield laws that explicitly apply regardless of patient location offers its providers the strongest protections for delivering care through telehealth, including to out-of-state patients. States should prioritize enacting legislation with explicit protections for telehealth regardless of patient location to exponentially expand access to care.

02

Protect Against Another State’s Laws and Judgments Penalizing Health Care

Both states and private actors have used civil lawsuits (PDF, opens in a new tab) to attempt to penalize health care providers for offering reproductive and gender-affirming care. Some shield states have enacted laws preventing their courts from enforcing the laws or judgments of another state that penalize abortion and gender-affirming care. Others have enacted “clawback provisions” enabling those subjected to out-of-state lawsuits related to protected care to recover damages from hostile litigation. States should prioritize protecting providers from the civil laws and judgments of states that ban and restrict health care.

03

Protect Provider Privacy on Medication Labels

Providers in shield law states care for abortion seekers from states where the provision of care is criminalized, as well as abortion seekers living in unsafe homes or who are subject to increased surveillance by law enforcement, immigration enforcement, or family regulation systems. Anti-abortion extremists in Louisiana and Texas have brought legal actions against telehealth shield providers claiming they discovered their names on a medication abortion pill label. Allowing providers to remove their names from medication abortion pill labels helps providers offer care privately and with less fear of detection and legal jeopardy. States should prioritize enacting protections for provider privacy on medication labels.

04

Prevent Disclosure of Patients’ Medical Information

Research shows that criminal cases brought against people for self-managed abortions (PDF, opens in a new tab) and other pregnancy outcomes (PDF, opens in a new tab) are commonly brought to the attention of law enforcement by health care providers. Although federal law under HIPAA offers some privacy protection for patients’ medical information, HIPAA contains exceptions that some providers have interpreted as permitting them to disclose sensitive patient health information to law enforcement. To counter this, some shield states have enacted more comprehensive privacy protections against health care providers and related entities disclosing a patient’s health information where it may be used to investigate or penalize lawful abortion or gender-affirming care.

Several shield states have also enacted specific protections responding to our interoperable electronic health record system, where medical records may be automatically shared across state lines through health information exchanges (HIEs). HIEs may automatically transfer data from states where abortion and gender-affirming care is lawful to states where it is banned and heavily surveilled. Recognizing this risk, some shield states have enacted laws requiring heightened security within electronic health records for information related to reproductive and gender-affirming care and prohibiting that information from being shared across state lines through HIEs. States should prioritize legislation that prevents disclosure of patients’ medical information.

Opens your browser's print dialog. Choose Save as PDF.